John records some very interesting interactions between the chief priest and Pilate in Chapters 18 and 19 of his Gospel. I believe it is fair to say that there was no love lost between these two.
I am going to start with John and point out one sentence in 18:16. John, who does not identify himself, says he was known to the high priest. To me, this important and should refute the idea of Jesus picking “poor, uneducated fisherman”. To be able to walk into the chief priest palace and talk to a female doorkeeper to get Peter in is quite a feat. The easy explanation is that it had to do with fish deliveries, that is my guess on the subject. A few other notes here seem timely: the Upper Room seems to have belonged to John and James’ sister, and John Mark was their cousin. That also makes Barnabas a relative. I think there was “a lot of family” in the Gospel stories and Acts.
Chief Priest – Sources (see below) make it clear that the office of high priest was bought from Herod or Rome. Those moneychangers and animal sellers were part of a well-lubricated money-making enterprise.
Annas/Ananias (See Acts 24) is a family name and there were several men who had that name and served a high priest. (From a Google search.)
It is important and fair to note that not all priest were corrupt or even Sadducees.
Pilate – I think every Jesus movie made portrays Pilate a little different, but that’s Hollywood. Pilate and his soldiers make up the Gentile component for the crucifixion. They did not conquer their known world by being nice. John 18 and 19 contains the drama that is recorded between Caiaphas, the high priest, and Pilate. Including the other Gospel accounts will complete the picture.
Chapter 18:
- 28 – the Jews had Pilate come out to them. I am sure he did not like that.
- 30 – the priest did not answer Pilate about the charges against Jesus.
- 31a – “judge him by your own Law” is Pilate being nice and saying leave me alone.
- 31b – they did not “want to be guilty” of actually killing Jesus. They could always cast shade on Rome. Stoning Jesus would have been fast, but hanging on an etz was a curse.
- 33-37 Pilate’s private conversation with Jesus. The Jews could not go in to listen; know that made them mad.
- 38b – “I find no charge against Him.” Pilate saw what the high priest was doing, he was to kill Jesus and they could always blame him and Rome.
- 39 – Release the “king of the Jews.” Pilate saw a way out and take a jab at Herod and the political structure in Jerusalem.
- 40 – Barabbas, being part of the fourth major political/religious party in Israel (Zealot) was not a friend of the Sadducees or Herod. I bet the priest were very smug about yelling that choice. Barabbas was a Roman killer.
Chapter 19:
- 5 – “Here is the man.” O, I have heard some great sermons on that one phrase. It does give you the fact that had no clue who Jesus was, but I bet he had heard about the miracles and the crowds.
- 7 – “He claimed to be the Son of God.” Finally, the charge Pilate had asked for in 18:29, and that made him uncomfortable. Remember, Rome was polytheistic and their gods were always making babies, especially with humans. Sounds like the fallen angels before and right after the Flood in Genesis.
- 8 – 12a Here it would be good to look at the other Gospels, especially Matthew 27:19, which tells about Pilate’s wife warning him about Jesus. You may speculate all you want as to why Pilate wanted to let Him go. I do not know, but for this post, it was to make the Jews mad;( The death of one more Jew, probably meant very little to Pilate.
- 12b-16 This is the Jews trump card over Pilate, threaten to tell Caesar. His final solution was in Matthew 27:24, wash his hands, and crucify Jesus. Note, that the Jews “friend and king”, Caesar, destroyed Jerusalem and their temple forty years later.
- Pilate’s final words: JESUS OF NAZARETH, THE KING OF THE JEWS. I have no doubt that he loved telling the high priest, NO, when they demanded that he change it.
A time frame for all of this, including a trip to Herod, is relevant.
- John 18:28 The trial with Pilate started very early in the morning (6 a.m.). Pilate may have been pulled from bed for this. Talk about a lot of drama packed into three hours.
- Mark 15:25 Jesus was on the cross, with the “notice of charge” by 9 a.m. (third hour).
- Matthew 27:45 From noon to 3 p.m. (6th to 9th hour) it was dark. Then Jesus ended it. In my dramatic mind, noon was when Pilate told the Jews no and when he said it the darkness fell.
Herod the Great – Chabad.org priest paid for the office
Topical Bible: The High Priest: Office of, Made Annual by the Romans